Labour policy: Education (Evaluation)

Under the Tories, the break up of the comprehensive system began with the creation of new kinds of schools - city technology colleges (CTCs) and grant-maintained(GM) schools - and the publication of league tables of exam results with parents allowed to express a preference for their child to leave their catchment area school for one they considered better. Grammar schools remained in some areas. GM schools received extra funding and the private sector had always had financial help. Powers were taken from Local Education Authorities (LEAs), and central control was maintained through the National Curriculum, Ofsted inspections, hit squads for failing schools (?), etc. Class sizes rose and many school buildings needed extensive repairs. Student grant levels were frozen, and so had to be supplemented by increasingly large loans.
Labour policy was:
1An end to grammar schools
2An end to GM schools
3Restoration of comprehensive state education
4An end to the Assisted Places Scheme for private education
5Less league tables comparing schools more fairly by giving value-added data
6LEAs to be valued once more as accountable local service providers
7Ofsted inspections to be less confrontational and to help schools improve (?)
8To reduce class sizes to below 30
9To have a major programme to repair school buildings
10A student grant system helping those most in need and widening access
In fact under New Labour:
1All the grammar schools remain in a system biased towards keeping themLeft as under the Conservatives
2GM schools were in effect renamed as Foundation schools, kept their extra funding for many years and often still get it in other waysLeft as under the Conservatives
3Comprehensive schools are now damned as a failed "one-size-fits-all" model, there are even more separate categories of schools and they can diverge more in their curriculaPolicy shift to right of old Conservatives
4The scheme was abolishedPledge carried out
5There are even more league tables and when value-added data were published in 2007 they were an addition not a replacement for raw dataPledge partially carried out
6LEAs have lost more powers and there will be a presumption against them running any new schoolsPolicy shift to right of old Conservatives
7Ofsted inspections were not changed by government, so attitudes depend on who is running the system, [?]Pledge partially carried out
8Class sizes are below 30 for 5-7 year olds, but up for older childrenPledge partially carried out
9The major repair programme was achievedPledge carried out
10Grants were first abolished then reintroduced for the poor, but variable tuition fees threaten to restrict their access to more expensive coursesPledge partially carried out
In addition:
Bullet pointThe private sector is now running "failing" state schools and whole LEAs, and will be allowed to provide more services for other schools
Bullet pointBy 2001 schools received government funding in 71 different ways, making it hard to check whether funding is fair
Bullet pointFree nursery places and SureStart schemes give more early years support

No comments:

Post a Comment